
Cheap Fire Island Hire Car & Car Rentals
Featured partner agencies
Top Car Hire Deals in Fire Island
Economy

Compact

Midsize

SUV

Top hotel deals in Fire Island

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Red Roof Inn PLUS+ Long Island - Garden City

Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge by IHG

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

Hilton Garden Inn Melville

Hyatt Place Garden City

Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City, NY

Danfords Hotel and Marina

SureStay Plus by Best Western Woodbury Inn

Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma
All the FAQs about car hire in Fire Island
Can I get cheap car hire in Fire Island?
On Wotif absolutely! per day is currently the lowest price in a fantastic list of deals we have for cheap car rental in Fire Island.
What’s the average cost of car hire in Fire Island per day?
The average cost of car rental in Fire Island is in the list of deals we have currently available. Of course, that’ll change depending on pick-up location, dates, and the kind of car you want.
What type of car can I rent in Fire Island?
Wotif has an awesome selection of car rentals in Fire Island. Think fun city rides in budget-friendly compacts to open-road thrills in stylish sports cars and more. Use the Car Type filter to choose your favourite and we’ll get you moving.
Which is the best car rental in Fire Island?
Wotif compares prices from top Fire Island car hire companies. Narrow down your choice with the easy-to-use filters and book your epic deals with the best car rental company for you.
Where can I rent a car in Fire Island?
At Wotif, we have great deals on super-convenient car-rental locations around Fire Island – you may want to get your car at the airport, in the centre, or near where you’re staying. Just stick your travel dates in Wotif’s search, use the customising filters and, voila, it’ll magic up loads of fantastic options for car rentals in Fire Island to suit you best.
I need to change my Wotif car hire booking. Can you help?
Of course! Our flexible cancellation policy makes it easy. To change any part of your car booking, simply cancel your existing one and rebook a new itinerary. In most cases, you won’t be charged a penalty.
How do I cancel my Wotif car rental booking?
To cancel your car hire booking, sign in, and head to Manage Booking and click Cancel Reservation. If you booked your car hire as part of a holiday package, refer to Wotif’s customer service portal for help. You must cancel a prepaid car rental reservation 6 hours before pick-up to qualify for a full refund.
Can I rent a car if I’m under 25 in Fire Island?
Some rental companies may let you hire a car in Fire Island if you’re under 25. The best thing to do is check with the individual car supplier before booking.
Can I rent a car long term in Fire Island through Wotif?
Yes. Many companies offer affordable car rental deals in Fire Island for long-term hire – in fact, it's often cheaper than short-term rental. Select your pick up location and travel dates then hit Search to see all the great options available.
Why should I hire a car in Fire Island using Wotif?
We partner with top car hire agencies so you can select your perfect ride – from roomy SUVs to nippy run-arounds. Last-minute change of plans? No worries! It’s simple and, in most cases, free to cancel and rebook. And if you need to book hotels and flights, you can mix and match with Wotif for extra savings.
What are the advantages of hiring a car with Wotif in Fire Island?
Car rental in Fire Island gives you the flexibility and freedom for a truly fantastic getaway that runs on your schedule. Style, comfort, and quality come as standard whether you’re in an executive ride or a compact coupe – Wotif has the wheels you need.